I love Craigslist for a variety of reasons, the main one being that you can find killer deals on random items. We got our leather couches, Pottery Barn TV hutch, and one of our cars off Craigslist. When we lived in Dayton for a summer, I furnished our house courtesy of Goodwill and Wal-Mart, then sold it all (for a profit) on Craigslist at the end of the summer. Lately, I've been on the selling end again and today I had a funny experience.

I'm now on my third round trying to give away a brand new pack of adult Depends. We got them last Thanksgiving when Andy's family thought it might be a good way to keep Ben dry during the night, but alas, it didn't work. Too big and unwieldy. Anyways, my thrifty self can't just throw away a pack of perfectly good Depends, so I've listed them for free two other times. Each time I get multiple responses within hours and arrange for them to be picked up, but no one has ever come. Everyone always says they're for their aging grandparent, uncle, aunt, etc. but maybe they think I'll assume they're really going to use them. I really don't care at this point - I just want them gone! Right now they're taking up valuable real estate in my coat closet. I'm contemplating hosting a white elephant gift exchange just because they'd be the perfect gag gift.
Anyway, I got five responses today, one of which killed me. Apologies for those who are squeamish, but a summary wouldn't do it justice. And I quote: "I would like to have these, as they are great for my period at night and do WAAY better than sanitary napkins! Please let me know so I can pick them up Wednesday." Wow. Serious oversharing. I know Craigslist creates its own cozy little community, but this isn't Facebook, people.
I responded that she could pick them up at her leisure tomorrow, I'd leave them in a bag on our doorstep. Totally incognito. She then followed up with an email asking if I could meet her at a Wendy's in town tomorrow because she catches the bus there. On one hand if she really needs them that bad, I should be a Good Samaritan, but on the other hand, is this a trip into crazytown? What to do?
Have you had any memorable Craigslist experiences?